Here’s something that could be helpful for those of you who think there’s a perfect plane to a golf swing.
The simple answer, is that there is no perfect plane in a golf swing. For one, Hogan claims in his book that the reason he used the swing plane concept was to get his backswing in a “consistent slot” but not an effort to say there’s such thing as a perfect plane.
Also, as you can notice in the pictures below, depending on your height and build, your swing plane may be flatter or more upright than the standard so there’s no use in trying to copy your favorite pro’s swing plane unless you are exactly the same height and build.
You can easily see that Tiger’s legs are noticeably longer than his upper body length compared to Ben Hogan. Because of this, Tiger’s swing is naturally more upright than Ben Hogan’s. Also, Tiger is 6′ 2″ while Ben Hogan is 5′ 8″.
These vast difference in physical makeup prove that there’s no such thing as a perfect plane for any golfer.
The swing plane I used in swing analysis was to simply have a reference point of how the golfer is swinging but in the recent months, I’ve began to realize that it’s not the most important factor in a good golf swing.
I’ve seen a ton of great swings that are far from golf norms, some way too flat or some way too upright.
The bottom line is, you need to build a consistent golf swing, not a swing that depends on lines drawn on the computer.
If you can hit a 200 yard target with a 4-iron 10 out of 10 times and you have what I think the worst swing in golf, I will not tell you to change your swing.
However, you can’t do that and your head is filled with swing mechanics garbage, perhaps I will tell you to focus on golf swing basics.
Golf swing basics consist of your grip, body action, and starting your downswing with your hips followed by your upper body. In simpler terms, the more you can build a “consistent” swing, however you do it, it will work. But you can’t really get consistency by building a perfect swing, there is no such thing. Everyone has their own quirks and personal touch.
I’ve fiddled with a high-speed digital camera for about 10 years, trying to perfect my swing. Sometimes I try to copy Tiger’s or Ben’s but none of those things ever seemed to bring consistency. I threw my high-speed camera away and started building a golf swing I felt was more natural and right to me and I think I am on my way to a more consistent golf swing.
Don’t copy but learn and apply the basic fundamentals, that’s what they did too.
Lastly, a “swing plane” does help me “visualize” a consistent path for my backswing and that is really its real purpose so I can get consistent results. If you keep drawing lines on your golf swing video/photos, it ain’t gonna help you with your golf swing. Your swing might look “great” but underlying performance probably won’t improve at all.
Find a swing plane that works for you, find the one that you hit the best, crisp shots with both irons and woods. Then stick with that swing plane. It’s that simple. And I could really care less if you swung like Jim Furyk or Ben Hogan if you can hit the ball good.